Criminal Justice (Courts)

signed · Vermont · House Apr 2, 2025

H 2: An act relating to increasing the minimum age for delinquency proceedings

This bill raises Vermont's minimum age for juvenile delinquency proceedings from 10 to 12 years old. It also increases the age threshold for transferring youth to adult court from 19 to 20 years old, meaning youth aged 16-17 committing offenses will now remain in juvenile court until age 21 (previously 20), and those aged 18 will stay until age 22 (previously 21). The law directly affects youth aged 12-20 involved in delinquency cases, keeping them in the juvenile justice system longer. Implementation requires the Agency of Human Services to report progress on facility and program expansions by 2026, with full implementation effective July 1, 2027.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeRaises juvenile age thresholds to keep youth in rehabilitation-focused system longer, reducing adult court exposure and aligning with reform goals to improve outcomes and reduce recidivism.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Courts Juvenile Justice

passed · Vermont · House Jan 15, 2026

H 409: An act relating to appeals of orders denying bail revocation

H.409 updates Vermont's bail revocation rules to align with court rulings like *State v. Sauve*. It clarifies when a defendant’s bail can be revoked - such as repeated failures to appear in court or violating release conditions that disrupt prosecutions - and requires courts to find a "compelling State interest" before revoking bail. Prosecutors must prove violations by a "preponderance of evidence" (more likely than not), and courts must schedule a trial within 60 days of revocation if the defendant remains jailed. This directly affects defendants on pretrial release, prosecutors seeking revocation, and courts managing bail hearings.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeRequires 'compelling State interest' and 'preponderance of evidence' for bail revocation, protecting defendant rights and aligning with court rulings to prevent arbitrary detention.85% confidence

Sub-Topics Courts

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Feb 12, 2025

H 201: An act relating to prohibiting discrimination based on an individual’s criminal history

This bill prohibits discrimination based on criminal history in employment and housing across Vermont. It adds "criminal history" to Vermont's existing anti-discrimination laws, meaning employers cannot refuse to hire or landlords cannot deny housing solely due to an individual's criminal record. The law includes exceptions for jobs where federal or state law mandates disqualification (e.g., for certain crimes in childcare roles) or for positions substantially related to the offense. It also defines "criminal history" broadly to cover all contact with the criminal justice system, including arrests and court dispositions.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeProhibits criminal history discrimination in employment/housing, reducing reintegration barriers and aligning with criminal justice reform goals to lower recidivism.95% confidence ✓ HousingSupports HousingProhibits housing discrimination based on criminal history, directly protecting tenant rights and expanding housing access for individuals with records.95% confidence ✓ Labor & EmploymentSupports Labor & EmploymentBill prohibits employment discrimination based on criminal history, protecting workers' rights and strengthening hiring standards by preventing unfair exclusion from jobs.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Civil Rights Courts

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Feb 18, 2025

H 251: An act relating to establishing a competency restoration process

H 251 establishes a legal process to help criminal defendants found incompetent to stand trial regain competency through mental health treatment. The bill requires courts to provide structured treatment services for defendants unable to understand trial proceedings due to mental health conditions, while including community safety safeguards. It directly affects Vermont defendants in criminal cases who are deemed incompetent to stand trial. The process aims to restore competency for fair trials or appropriate resolution, with specific court procedures outlined in the bill.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeBill establishes competency restoration process via mental health treatment for defendants, promoting fair trials and rehabilitation while including safety safeguards, aligning with criminal justice reform indicators.92% confidence ✓ HealthcareSupports HealthcareBill mandates court-provided mental health treatment for defendants deemed incompetent, directly advancing mental health services access per topic description.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Courts Mental Health

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Feb 25, 2025

H 331: An act relating to a victim’s right to be heard at an appeal or postconviction remedy hearing

This bill requires Vermont prosecutors to inform victims of certain crimes when a defendant appeals or seeks postconviction relief, explaining the process and providing hearing details. It mandates that courts at these hearings ask victims if they wish to speak about the case and consider their statements. Victims who cannot attend must have their written or oral views considered by the court. The law applies to victims of specified crimes and takes effect July 1, 2025. This changes how victims participate in legal proceedings after a conviction.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeBill mandates victim participation in appeals, strengthening victim rights and procedural fairness in criminal justice proceedings.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Courts Victims' Rights

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Feb 11, 2025

H 176: An act relating to developing the Department of Corrections’ community restitution program

H 176 requires Vermont's Department of Corrections to reinstate its community work program (called "work crew") by July 1, 2025, after it was discontinued in 2023. The bill mandates reinstating prior policies and sets minimum requirements: offenders must be assigned at least 20 work crew days per court order, or 60 days total across multiple orders. This directly affects individuals sentenced to community restitution and the Department of Corrections, which must implement the program by the deadline. The law takes effect upon passage.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeReinstates community restitution program requiring work crew days, promoting rehabilitation over incarceration - aligns with reform indicators.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Corrections Courts Victims' Rights

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Jan 23, 2025

H 64: An act relating to after-hours access to orders against sexual assault

H 64 creates a process for victims of sexual assault to obtain emergency protective orders outside regular court hours, weekends, and holidays. It requires the Court Administrator to establish procedures where an authorized person can receive requests (including electronically), administer a sworn statement over the phone, and relay the case to a judicial officer for a decision. This directly affects individuals seeking immediate protection from sexual assault when courts are closed. The judicial officer decides solely based on the submitted information, and if approved, the order is delivered to law enforcement for service. The bill takes effect September 1, 2025.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeCreates emergency court access for sexual assault victims, improving victim protection and access to justice within criminal court procedures.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Courts Domestic Violence Law Enforcement

Track

passed · Vermont · House Feb 6, 2026

H 5: An act relating to a hearsay exception for a child under 16 years of age

H.5 amends Vermont's evidence rules to allow statements made by children aged 12-15 who are victims of specific abuse crimes (like sexual assault, cruelty, or exploitation) to be used as evidence in court. The bill requires courts to verify that such statements are trustworthy, made before legal proceedings began, and not prepared for trial. It directly affects child victims in criminal, civil, or juvenile cases involving listed abuse offenses under Vermont law. The change takes effect July 1, 2025, and applies only to cases where the child’s statements relate to the alleged abuse.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeEnables use of child victims' statements in abuse cases, strengthening prosecution of sexual assault/cruelty crimes under Vermont law while requiring trustworthiness verification.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Courts Juvenile Justice Violent Crime

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Feb 12, 2025

H 200: An act relating to persons prohibited from possessing firearms

H 200 prohibits Vermont residents found by a court to pose a danger to themselves or others due to mental illness from possessing firearms. This new rule applies to individuals under specific court orders for mental health treatment or hospitalization, aligning Vermont law with federal standards. The bill also increases penalties for second or subsequent offenses of firearm possession by prohibited persons, raising the maximum penalty to three years in jail or a $5,000 fine. It does not change existing prohibitions for other reasons, such as violent crime convictions.

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeRestricts firearm access for high-risk individuals (mental health court orders) and increases penalties for violations, aligning with federal standards to prevent gun violence, a key criminal justice reform goal.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Corrections Courts Firearms

Track

introduced · Vermont · House Feb 26, 2025

H 379: An act relating to second look sentencing

H 379 creates a "second look" sentencing process in Vermont for incarcerated individuals serving 15+ years. It allows people who have served at least 15 years to petition their original sentencing court for a sentence reduction, directly affecting those currently serving long sentences (including life sentences or 50+ year terms). Key mechanisms include mandatory notice to the court, prosecutor, and public defender after 15 years of incarceration, a structured petition process with required documentation, and expedited hearings for those with serious health conditions or who are 60+ years old after 25 years served. The bill aims to reduce Vermont's high rate of life-sentence inmates (20% of the incarcerated population) and lower annual incarceration costs ($134,218 per person).

Topics ✓ Criminal JusticeSupports Criminal JusticeEnables sentence reduction petitions after 15+ years, promoting rehabilitation and reducing long-term incarceration - core criminal justice reform.95% confidence

Sub-Topics Corrections Courts Sentencing

Track