Immunizations: medical exemptions.
What changed between versions
The bill's scope was expanded from a single technical amendment to Section 1250.06 (hospital chemical labeling) to a multi-code overhaul spanning the Business and Professions Code, Health and Safety Code, and Insurance Code, covering immunization medical exemptions comprehensively.
New Article 16 added to the Business and Professions Code (Sections 2380-2383) defining 'medical exemption' and establishing that physicians cannot be investigated, disciplined, or acted against by any state department or board based on issuing a medical exemption unless it is found fraudulent or otherwise invalid.
Section 120370 was repealed and re-added with a simpler standard: a child is exempt if a parent files a written statement from a licensed physician that immunization is not safe. The new version requires physicians to use 'accepted standards of care' rather than criteria established by the state department, effectively removing the state's ability to set its own medical exemption criteria.
Section 120375 was amended to prohibit schools from requiring disclosure of diagnosis or disability in support of a medical exemption, to classify medical exemption documentation as confidential medical information that cannot be disclosed without written consent (except to verify existence or by court order), and to prohibit sharing exemption status without written consent.
The old Section 120372 (which established a standardized electronic form, monitoring systems for physicians submitting 5+ exemptions, departmental review and revocation authority, and reporting to medical boards) was entirely repealed. The new Section 120372 prohibits the department, local health departments, or third-party panels from revoking, invalidating, or conditioning a medical exemption except by final court order upon clear and convincing evidence of fraud.
Section 120372.05 was repealed, eliminating the entire administrative appeals process including the independent expert review panel of three physicians that had been established to review revoked exemptions.
New Section 1272.5 prohibits health facilities from denying medically necessary care on the basis of a medical exemption, creating a new criminal offense (misdemeanor) for violations.
New Section 1374.199 prohibits health care service plans from denying coverage, imposing higher premiums, canceling policies, or otherwise penalizing an enrollee because a covered minor holds a medical exemption. Violation is a willful crime under the Knox-Keene Act.
New Section 10127.22 of the Insurance Code prohibits health insurers from denying coverage, imposing higher premiums, canceling policies, or otherwise penalizing an insured because a covered minor holds a medical exemption.
Section 12 requires the State Department of Public Health to repeal or amend any regulation inconsistent with the act on or before July 1, 2027.
The fiscal committee designation changed from 'no' to 'yes' and the state-mandated local program designation changed from 'no' to 'yes,' reflecting the new criminal penalties that trigger reimbursement obligations under the California Constitution.