H 5170 South Carolina House · 2023-2024 Regular Session

Judicial Merit Selection Commission, reform

Summary
A BILL TO AMEND THE SOUTH CAROLINA CODE OF LAWS BY AMENDING CHAPTER 19 OF TITLE 2, BY RENAMING THE CHAPTER THE "SOUTH CAROLINA JUDICIAL MERIT SELECTION COMMISSION, SCREENING AND ELECTION OF JUSTICES AND JUDGES", SO AS TO CREATE THE NEW SOUTH CAROLINA JUDICIAL MERIT SELECTION COMMISSION AND RESTRUCTURE THE PROCESS BY WHICH JUSTICES AND JUDGES ARE SCREENED AND ELECTED, TO PROVIDE FOR THE MEMBERSHIP OF THE COMMISSION AND ITS LIMITED TERMS, TO REQUIRE THE COMMISSION TO HAVE AN EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR AND OTHER NECESSARY STAFF, TO REQUIRE THE RELEASE OF ALL QUALIFIED JUDICIAL CANDIDATES, TO CREATE A COMBINED BAR AND CITIZENS' JUDICIAL QUALIFICATIONS COMMITTEE, TO CREATE A MIDTERM JUDICIAL BALLOT BOX REVIEW, TO GIVE DELEGATIONS THE AUTHORITY TO REJECT A MASTER-IN-EQUITY CANDIDATE IN ADDITION TO THE GOVERNOR'S AUTHORITY TO DO SO, TO CREATE A SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE COMMISSION TO SCREEN MAGISTRATE CANDIDATES BEFORE THE GOVERNOR APPOINTS, AMONG OTHER THINGS AND TO MAKE OTHER CONFORMING CHANGES; BY AMENDING SECTION 22-1-10, RELATING TO THE APPOINTMENT OF MAGISTRATES, SO AS TO PROVIDE THAT A MAGISTRATE MAY SERVE IN HOLDOVER STATUS FOR NO MORE THAN FOURTEEN DAYS AT THE END OF HIS TERM, TO PROVIDE THAT THE GOVERNOR MAY APPOINT A TEMPORARY MAGISTRATE UNDER CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES, AND TO PROVIDE THAT ANY MAGISTRATE OR MAGISTRATE CANDIDATE WHO HAS BEEN REPRIMANDED BY THE SUPREME COURT OR ANY OTHER DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY MAY NOT BE APPOINTED OR REAPPOINTED UNLESS APPROVED BY A MAJORITY OF THE SENATE AFTER THE SENATE IS INFORMED OF THE REPRIMAND OR DISCIPLINARY ACTION; BY AMENDING SECTION 22-3-10, RELATING TO THE CIVIL JURISDICTION OF THE MAGISTRATES COURT, SO AS TO INCREASE THE CIVIL JURISDICTION FROM SEVEN THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS TO TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS; AND BY AMENDING SECTION 22-3-550, RELATING TO MAGISTRATES COURT CRIMINAL JURISDICTION OVER MINOR OFFENSES, SO AS TO INCREASE THE PENALTY TO ONE YEAR AND INCREASE THE FINE OR FORFEITURE JURISDICTION FROM FIVE HUNDRED TO TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS; AND TO DIRECT THE DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATION TO CONDUCT AN ANALYSIS OF OFFICE SPACE AND OTHER RELEVANT INFORMATION AND REPORT TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY THE COSTS OF THE TRANSFER OF THE JUDICIAL MERIT SELECTION COMMISSION TO INDEPENDENT OFFICE SPACE WHEN IT CONVERTS TO THE SOUTH CAROLINA JUDICIAL MERIT SELECTION COMMISSION, AND TO PROVIDE THAT THE STANDALONE, INDEPENDENT AGENCY MUST BE CREATED AND FUNCTIONAL BY JULY 1, 2025.
Bill status in committee 1 of 4 stages cleared
Introduction
Feb 2024
Committee Review
Floor Vote
Governor
Introduced Feb 28, 2024 Last action May 7, 2024
Floor votes

How they voted

No floor votes recorded yet.
Full legislative history

Actions timeline

Total actions
4
Key actions
0
Committee
1
Feb 28, 2024
Committee
Referred to Committee on Judiciary
lower
Feb 28, 2024
Introduced
Introduced and read first time
lower
60 primary · 0 co-sponsors

Sponsors

Role
Legislator
Party
State
District
P
Photo of Anne Thayer
Anne Thayer
RRepublican
SC
9
P
Photo of Annie McDaniel
Annie McDaniel
DDemocratic
SC
41
P
Photo of Bart Blackwell
Bart Blackwell
RRepublican
SC
81
P
Photo of Ben Connell
Ben Connell
RRepublican
SC
52
P
Photo of Beth Bernstein
Beth Bernstein
DDemocratic
SC
78
P
Photo of Bill Hager
Bill Hager
RRepublican
SC
122
P
Photo of Bill Herbkersman
Bill Herbkersman
RRepublican
SC
118
P
Photo of Bill Hixon
Bill Hixon
RRepublican
SC
83
P
Photo of Bill Sandifer
Bill Sandifer
RRepublican
SC
2
P
Photo of Bill Taylor
Bill Taylor
RRepublican
SC
86
P
Photo of Bobby Cox
Bobby Cox
RRepublican
SC
21
P
Photo of Brandon Cox
Brandon Cox
RRepublican
SC
92
P
Photo of Brandon Guffey
Brandon Guffey
RRepublican
SC
48
P
Photo of Brandon Newton
Brandon Newton
RRepublican
SC
45
P
Photo of Bruce Bannister
Bruce Bannister
RRepublican
SC
24
P
Photo of Cal Forrest
Cal Forrest
RRepublican
SC
39
P
Photo of Carla Schuessler
Carla Schuessler
RRepublican
SC
61
P
Photo of Case Brittain
Case Brittain
RRepublican
SC
107
P
Photo of Chandra Dillard
Chandra Dillard
DDemocratic
SC
23
P
Photo of Chris Wooten
Chris Wooten
RRepublican
SC
69
P
Photo of Cody Mitchell
Cody Mitchell
RRepublican
SC
65
P
Photo of Craig Gagnon
Craig Gagnon
RRepublican
SC
11
P
Photo of Fawn Pedalino
Fawn Pedalino
RRepublican
SC
64
P
Photo of Gil Gatch
Gil Gatch
RRepublican
SC
94
P
Photo of Gilda Cobb-Hunter
Gilda Cobb-Hunter
DDemocratic
SC
95
P
Photo of Heath Sessions
Heath Sessions
RRepublican
SC
46
P
Photo of Heather Bauer
Heather Bauer
DDemocratic
SC
75
P
Photo of Heather Crawford
Heather Crawford
RRepublican
SC
68
P
Photo of Ivory Thigpen
Ivory Thigpen
DDemocratic
SC
79
P
Photo of Jason Elliott
Jason Elliott
RRepublican
SC
6
P
Photo of Jay Jordan
Jay Jordan
RRepublican
SC
63
P
Photo of Jay West
Jay West
RRepublican
SC
7
P
Photo of Jeff Bradley
Jeff Bradley
RRepublican
SC
123
P
Photo of Jeff Johnson
Jeff Johnson
RRepublican
SC
58
P
Photo of Jerry Carter
Jerry Carter
RRepublican
SC
3
P
Photo of Joe White
Joe White
RRepublican
SC
40
P
Photo of John King
John King
DDemocratic
SC
49
P
Photo of Josiah Magnuson
Josiah Magnuson
RRepublican
SC
38
P
Photo of Justin Bamberg
Justin Bamberg
DDemocratic
SC
90
P
Photo of Kevin Hardee
Kevin Hardee
RRepublican
SC
105
P
Photo of Mark Smith
Mark Smith
RRepublican
SC
99
P
Photo of Marvin Pendarvis
Marvin Pendarvis
DDemocratic
SC
113
P
Photo of Matt Leber
Matt Leber
RRepublican
SC
41
P
Photo of Max Hyde
Max Hyde
RRepublican
SC
32
P
Photo of Micah Caskey
Micah Caskey
RRepublican
SC
89
P
Photo of Murrell Smith
Murrell Smith
RRepublican
SC
67
P
Photo of Patrick Haddon
Patrick Haddon
RRepublican
SC
19
P
Photo of Randy Ligon
Randy Ligon
RRepublican
SC
43
P
Photo of Raye Felder
Raye Felder
RRepublican
SC
26
P
Photo of Richie Yow
Richie Yow
RRepublican
SC
53
P
Photo of Russell Ott
Russell Ott
DDemocratic
SC
26
P
Photo of Shannon Erickson
Shannon Erickson
RRepublican
SC
124
P
Photo of Spencer Wetmore
Spencer Wetmore
DDemocratic
SC
115
P
Photo of Tim McGinnis
Tim McGinnis
RRepublican
SC
56
P
Photo of Tommy Pope
Tommy Pope
RRepublican
SC
47
P
Photo of Travis Moore
Travis Moore
RRepublican
SC
33
P
Photo of Val Guest
Val Guest
RRepublican
SC
106
P
Photo of Weston Newton
Weston Newton
RRepublican
SC
120
P
Photo of Will Wheeler
Will Wheeler
DDemocratic
SC
50
P
Photo of William Bailey
William Bailey
RRepublican
SC
104