HB 791: Generally revise nuisance laws - Montana

HB0791_X(1).pdf → HB0791_X(2).pdf · 4 edits

MODERATE

The bill was amended to remove the repeal of several specific sections of the Montana Code Annotated, which likely means those laws remain in effect despite this bill. Additionally, the definition of 'government entity' was clarified to exclude federal, state, or local agencies from certain preemption rules, and the preemption clause was narrowed to only apply where common law conflicts with the new chapter. A new section was added establishing liability for public nuisance.

Scope change

The bill's scope was reduced by removing the repeal of existing statutes, and its applicability was narrowed by clarifying that federal, state, and local government entities are not subject to the preemption of common law nuisance claims.

SCOPE

Removed the repeal of sections 27-30-102, 27-30-103, 27-30-104, 27-30-105, 27-30-201, 27-30-202, 27-30-203, 27-30-301, and 27-30-302, meaning these laws will not be abolished by this bill.

DEFINITION

Modified the definition of 'government entity' to exclude federal, state, or local governmental entities or agencies from the scope of certain orders and notices.

ENFORCEMENT

Modified the preemption clause to limit the bill's authority to situations where common law is inconsistent with the chapter, rather than broadly abrogating all common law nuisance.

Added a new section establishing liability for public nuisance, allowing individuals to be subject to such claims.

HB0791_2(5).pdf → HB0791_X.pdf · 4 edits

MODERATE

The bill was finalized and formatted for official enactment, changing the document title from a draft to an 'Enrolled Bill'. The substantive text of the nuisance laws was significantly rewritten to clarify definitions, remove redundant language, and explicitly list exemptions for lawful activities like shooting range noises and agricultural operations. These changes aim to provide clearer legal standards for determining what constitutes a public or private nuisance.

Scope change

The bill's scope remains focused on revising Montana's nuisance laws, but the definitions of 'public nuisance' and 'private nuisance' were expanded and clarified to include specific exclusions that were previously ambiguous or missing.

DEFINITION

The definition of 'public nuisance' was rewritten to explicitly list actions that cannot be considered a nuisance, such as lawful activities, authorized government actions, and noises from shooting ranges during operating hours.

The definition of 'private nuisance' was similarly updated to clarify exemptions, including agricultural operations and authorized government activities, ensuring they are not automatically treated as nuisances.

TECHNICAL

The document was updated from a draft version (HB0791.2) to an official 'Enrolled Bill' (HB 791), indicating it has passed all legislative stages and is ready for signature.

Redundant and repetitive language was removed from the bill title and section headers to improve clarity and readability.

HB0791_1(8).pdf → HB0791_2.pdf · 4 edits

MODERATE

The bill significantly broadens the definition of public nuisance by explicitly including actions that violate government rules or permits, whereas the previous version only listed lawful actions as exceptions. It also adds a specific definition for private nuisance and clarifies that agricultural operations are not nuisances simply because they exist, provided they have been operating for a certain duration. These changes aim to standardize how nuisance claims are handled by ensuring that legally authorized activities are protected from nuisance lawsuits.

Scope change

The bill's scope expanded to explicitly cover violations of statutes, ordinances, and permits as factors that cannot be considered a public nuisance, and it introduced a new, detailed definition for private nuisance.

DEFINITION

Added a new section defining 'private nuisance' as a condition arising from real property use that injures health/safety or obstructs neighboring property use.

Modified the public nuisance definition to explicitly state that actions or conditions violating government statutes, ordinances, or permits are NOT considered a public nuisance.

Added a specific clause stating that agricultural or farming operations do not become a private nuisance simply due to changed residential conditions if they have been operating longer than the complaining resident has been in possession.

Expanded the list of factors that cannot be considered a public nuisance to include impairment of spiritual, cultural, or emotional significance of waterways.

LC2255.pdf → HB0791_1.pdf · 2 edits

MINOR

The bill was renumbered from LC 2255 to HB 791.1 and updated to an 'Authorized Print Version.' A new sentence was added to clarify that a new property owner is liable for public nuisances created by a previous owner if they fail to fix them, ensuring the nuisance is addressed regardless of ownership changes.

Scope change

The bill's scope remains focused on nuisance laws, but the liability section now explicitly includes successive property owners who neglect to abate nuisances created by prior owners.

REQUIREMENT

Added liability for successive property owners who fail to abate public nuisances created by former owners.

TECHNICAL

Updated bill number from LC 2255 to HB 791.1 and changed header to 'Authorized Print Version.'

Generally revise nuisance laws

What changed between versions

How they voted

Actions timeline

Sponsors