HB 212: Limit liability of agricultural vehicles - Montana

HB0212_3(5).pdf → HB0212_3(6).pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill underwent significant formatting and numbering reorganization, shifting from a narrative style to a structured definition list. Substantively, the definition of 'Commercial motor vehicle' was expanded to include vehicles with a gross vehicle weight of 26,001 pounds or more, broadening the scope of vehicles subject to commercial regulations. Other definitions like 'Bus' and 'Authorized agent' were renumbered but retained their original meanings.

Scope change

The scope of the bill was expanded to include heavier vehicles (26,001+ lbs) under the definition of 'Commercial motor vehicle', while the overall applicability of other sections was reorganized for clarity.

DEFINITION

The definition of 'Commercial motor vehicle' was expanded to include vehicles with a gross vehicle weight of 26,001 pounds or more, in addition to the existing gross combination weight criteria.

The definition of 'Bus' was renumbered and slightly reworded to clarify that it includes vehicles designed for carrying more than 10 passengers, excluding taxicabs.

TECHNICAL

The entire document structure was renumbered and reorganized from a narrative format into a structured list of definitions, improving readability and consistency.

HB0212_3(4).pdf → HB0212_3(5).pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill underwent minor formatting adjustments and a specific text correction regarding liability limits. The most significant change is the removal of the word 'DAMAGES' in the liability section, which clarifies that insurers are not liable for amounts exceeding the specified limits without creating a redundant or confusing definition. Additionally, the bill's title page was updated to reflect the 2025 legislative session, and the list of sponsoring legislators was slightly reorganized.

TECHNICAL

The word 'DAMAGES' was removed from the liability limitation clause to improve clarity and avoid redundancy in the text.

Minor formatting adjustments were made to the spacing and indentation of the agricultural vehicle definitions.

The bill's title page was updated to indicate the 2025 legislative session.

HB0212_3(3).pdf → HB0212_3(4).pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill adds a new section establishing a duty of care for operators of motor vehicles around agricultural vehicles, making unsafe driving behaviors like speeding prima facie evidence of negligence. It also expands the legal definition of 'agricultural vehicles' to include self-propelled units and vehicles used for hauling hay or straw, while simultaneously updating other vehicle definitions like 'bus' and 'commercial motor vehicle' to align with federal standards.

Scope change

The bill expands the scope of liability protections to cover a broader range of farm equipment and introduces new legal standards for how drivers must behave near agricultural vehicles.

REQUIREMENT

Added a new duty of care section requiring motor vehicle operators to exercise care toward people and livestock in agricultural vehicles, with speeding and erratic driving treated as prima facie evidence of breach of duty.

DEFINITION

Expanded the definition of 'agricultural vehicle' to include self-propelled farm equipment units and vehicles used for hauling hay or straw.

Updated the definition of 'bus' to include vehicles designed for transporting persons for compensation, and revised 'commercial motor vehicle' definitions to match federal weight thresholds.

HB0212_2(10).pdf → HB0212_3.pdf · 5 edits

MODERATE

The bill was renumbered from HB 212.2 to HB 212.3 and its effective date was changed to 'immediate' instead of a future date. The core policy language regarding liability limits for agricultural vehicles was removed and replaced with a new section establishing a 'duty of care' for vehicle operators toward people and livestock. Additionally, the definitions section was updated to include this new duty of care concept, while retaining other standard vehicle definitions.

Scope change

The bill's scope shifted from establishing specific financial liability caps for agricultural vehicle accidents to establishing a legal duty of care owed by operators to people and livestock, with specific behaviors like speeding serving as prima facie evidence of a breach of that duty.

TIMELINE

Changed the effective date from a future unspecified date to an immediate effective date.

REQUIREMENT

Added a new requirement that agricultural vehicle operators owe a duty of care to people and livestock.

Removed the specific liability cap of $750,000 per claim and $1.5 million per occurrence.

Established that speeding, erratic driving, or unsafe passing near agricultural vehicles is prima facie evidence of a breach of duty.

DEFINITION

Updated the definitions section to incorporate the new duty of care requirement and cross-reference the new section.

HB0212_1(7).pdf → HB0212_2(6).pdf · 4 edits

MODERATE

The bill underwent minor formatting adjustments to the header and sponsor list, while a significant substantive change was made to the liability section. The most important update clarifies that an insurer's exemption from paying excess damages only applies if the damages exceed the specific limits defined in Subsection (1), preventing insurers from using vague limitations to deny coverage.

Scope change

The scope of insurer liability was clarified to strictly tie the exemption from excess damages to the specific monetary limits outlined in the preceding subsection.

REQUIREMENT

Amended the insurer liability clause to explicitly state that the exemption from excess damages applies only when damages exceed the amounts identified in Subsection (1).

TECHNICAL

Inserted the phrase 'DAMAGES IN EXCESS OF THE AMOUNTS IDENTIFIED IN' to clarify the scope of the liability exemption.

Deleted the word 'SUBSECTION' from the original text, which was replaced by the more descriptive inserted text.

Adjusted the header and sponsor list formatting, including removing the sponsor 'E. TILLEMANN' and reformatting the legislature year.

HB0212_2(5).pdf → HB0212_1(7).pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill underwent minor formatting updates to standardize the header and bill number, while significantly expanding the scope of liability protections. The most important change is the addition of 'operator' to the list of individuals covered by insurance limitations for agricultural vehicles, ensuring that drivers are protected alongside owners and lessees. Additionally, the bill now explicitly includes vehicles controlled by farmers, their family members, or their employees, broadening the definition of who qualifies for these specific insurance rules.

Scope change

The bill's scope was expanded to include 'operators' of agricultural vehicles and to explicitly cover vehicles controlled by farmers, their family members, or their employees.

TECHNICAL

Header formatting was updated to change the bill number from HB0212.2 to HB 212.1 and removed redundant year text.

ELIGIBILITY

The list of individuals protected from excess liability was updated to include 'operator' alongside owner and lessee.

The definition of covered vehicles was expanded to include those controlled by farmers, their family members, or persons employed by them.

HB0212_1(6).pdf → HB0212_2.pdf · 3 edits

MINOR

The bill includes minor formatting adjustments to the header and sponsor list. A significant substantive change was added to the liability section, clarifying that insurers are not liable for damages exceeding the specific amounts defined in Subsection (1) unless they agree to cover them via a written endorsement. This clarification aims to prevent ambiguity regarding the limits of insurance coverage for agricultural vehicles.

Scope change

The scope of liability for insurers regarding agricultural vehicle damages was clarified to strictly limit coverage to amounts identified in Subsection (1) without a written waiver.

REQUIREMENT

Added explicit language stating that insurer liability for excess damages is limited to amounts in Subsection (1) unless a written endorsement is provided.

TECHNICAL

Inserted the word 'DAMAGES' to clarify the subject of the liability limitation.

Reformatted the header and sponsor list to correct line breaks and numbering.

LC1987.pdf → HB0212_1.pdf · 2 edits

MINOR

The bill text was updated from a committee version (LC 1987) to the final House Bill version (HB 212), including the full list of sponsors and the official title. The substantive policy content regarding liability limits for agricultural vehicles and the definitions of terms like 'agricultural vehicle' and 'commercial motor vehicle' remains identical to the previous version.

Scope change

The scope of the bill's policy has not changed; only the document metadata and formatting were updated to reflect the final legislative version.

TECHNICAL

The bill header was updated to change the identifier from 'LC 1987' to 'HB 212' and added the full list of sponsors who introduced the bill.

Page numbering and footer text were adjusted to match the new bill number and version type.

Limit liability of agricultural vehicles

What changed between versions

How they voted

Actions timeline

Sponsors